{ "schema_version": "fasttool-website-migration-benchmark-results/v1", "benchmark_version": "website-migration-benchmark-20260717", "engine": { "path": "app/js/renderers/website-migration-evidence-compiler-20260709a.js", "version": "20260709a", "sha256": "3f08e9ba6b24fb9a32843e6b81015da3c77154113a266882a54fc96f5d6cd805" }, "fixture": { "path": "fixtures/website-migration-benchmark-20260717/scenarios.json", "sha256": "b6119f07bea5376a009f57eac48826f0472cd8d5dda637c1abc82a8d1c71aa17" }, "result_policy": "Engine scenarios pass only when expectations, receipt-core verification, artifact hash parity and adapter exclusion checks all pass. Rollback capability gaps remain INDETERMINATE.", "scenario_count": 26, "engine_run_count": 24, "capability_boundary_count": 2, "passed_count": 26, "blocker_count": 0, "scenarios": [ { "id": "exact-one-to-one", "category": "mapping", "title_en": "Exact one-to-one paths", "title_tr": "Tam bire bir yollar", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 4, "new_url_count": 4, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 0, "risk_codes": [], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "prefix-directory-move", "category": "mapping", "title_en": "Prefix directory move is not assumed", "title_tr": "Dizin öneki taşıması varsayılmıyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "medium_confidence_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "ambiguous-near-tie", "category": "ambiguity", "title_en": "Two near-tie destinations", "title_tr": "Birbirine yakın iki hedef", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 6, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "candidate_collision", "medium_confidence_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "automatic-target-collision", "category": "collision", "title_en": "Two sources compete for one target", "title_tr": "İki kaynak tek hedef için yarışıyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 6, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 2, "risk_codes": [ "duplicate_target", "target_already_assigned" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "manual-duplicate-target", "category": "collision", "title_en": "Manual many-to-one collision", "title_tr": "Manuel çoktan bire çakışma", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 6, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 2, "risk_codes": [ "duplicate_target" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "redirect-chain", "category": "graph", "title_en": "Two-hop redirect chain", "title_tr": "İki adımlı yönlendirme zinciri", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 6, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 5, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "redirect_chain", "target_not_in_new_inventory" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "redirect-loop", "category": "graph", "title_en": "Closed redirect loop", "title_tr": "Kapalı yönlendirme döngüsü", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 6, "new_url_count": 4, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 2, "risk_codes": [ "redirect_loop", "target_not_in_new_inventory" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "meaningful-query-loss", "category": "query", "title_en": "Meaningful query key is lost", "title_tr": "Anlamlı sorgu anahtarı kayboluyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "query_parameter_loss", "query_specific_redirect_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "query-preserved-still-reviewed", "category": "query", "title_en": "Preserved query still needs policy review", "title_tr": "Korunan sorgu yine politika incelemesi istiyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "query_specific_redirect_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "tracking-query-normalization", "category": "query", "title_en": "Tracking parameter is removed only for matching", "title_tr": "İzleme parametresi yalnız eşleme için kaldırılıyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "query_specific_redirect_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "path-case-change", "category": "normalization", "title_en": "Path case change", "title_tr": "Yol harf büyüklüğü değişimi", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "medium_confidence_review" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "trailing-slash-preserved", "category": "normalization", "title_en": "Exact trailing slash is preserved", "title_tr": "Tam trailing slash korunuyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 5, "review_count": 0, "risk_codes": [], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "double-slash-blocked", "category": "normalization", "title_en": "Double slash remains visible and blocked", "title_tr": "Çift slash görünür kalıyor ve engelleniyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "unsupported_double_slash_path" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "excluded-removed-url", "category": "coverage", "title_en": "Removed URL receives no fabricated destination", "title_tr": "Kaldırılan URL için hedef uydurulmuyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 4, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "orphan_source" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "excluded-override-source", "category": "coverage", "title_en": "Override source excluded from inventory", "title_tr": "Envanter dışı override kaynağı", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 4, "new_url_count": 4, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 0, "risk_codes": [], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "no-destination", "category": "coverage", "title_en": "No destination candidate", "title_tr": "Hedef adayı yok", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "orphan_source" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "unexpected-cross-domain", "category": "origin", "title_en": "Unexpected cross-domain handoff", "title_tr": "Beklenmeyen alanlar arası geçiş", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "target_not_in_new_inventory", "unexpected_cross_domain_target" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "same-origin-target-not-in-inventory", "category": "coverage", "title_en": "Manual target absent from the new inventory", "title_tr": "Manuel hedef yeni envanterde yok", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 4, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "target_not_in_new_inventory" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "target-is-redirect", "category": "runtime-evidence", "title_en": "Target crawl row is another redirect", "title_tr": "Hedef crawl satırı başka bir yönlendirme", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "target_redirect_status" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "target-is-error", "category": "runtime-evidence", "title_en": "Target crawl row is an HTTP error", "title_tr": "Hedef crawl satırı HTTP hatası", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "target_http_error_status" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "invalid-override-status", "category": "input-validation", "title_en": "Invalid override status is rejected", "title_tr": "Geçersiz override durumu reddediliyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 5, "review_count": 0, "risk_codes": [], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "normalized-override-ambiguity", "category": "ambiguity", "title_en": "Tracking-only source variants make an override ambiguous", "title_tr": "Yalnız izleme parametresi farklı kaynaklar override'ı belirsizleştiriyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 6, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 2, "risk_codes": [ "duplicate_target", "query_specific_redirect_review", "target_already_assigned" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "unsafe-config-metacharacters", "category": "security", "title_en": "Server-config metacharacters", "title_tr": "Sunucu config metakarakterleri", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "review_risky_rows_before_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 4, "review_count": 1, "risk_codes": [ "target_not_in_new_inventory", "unsupported_config_metacharacter" ], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "non-301-adapter-boundary", "category": "adapter", "title_en": "308 is preserved in status-aware exports and excluded from Webflow", "title_tr": "308 durum duyarlı çıktılarda korunup Webflow'dan çıkarılıyor", "method": "engine_run", "expected_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "actual_decision": "ready_for_staged_redirect_qa", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": 5, "new_url_count": 5, "deployable_count": 5, "review_count": 0, "risk_codes": [], "receipt_core_valid": true, "artifact_hash_parity": true, "generated_artifact_count": 10 }, { "id": "rollback-baseline-missing", "category": "rollback", "title_en": "No previous redirect configuration is supplied", "title_tr": "Önceki yönlendirme yapılandırması sağlanmıyor", "method": "capability_boundary", "expected_decision": "INDETERMINATE", "actual_decision": "INDETERMINATE", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": null, "new_url_count": null, "deployable_count": null, "review_count": null, "risk_codes": [ "rollback_not_evaluated" ], "receipt_core_valid": null, "artifact_hash_parity": null, "generated_artifact_count": 10, "boundary": "The engine has no rollback-baseline input, so it cannot prove rollback coverage." }, { "id": "rollback-artifact-not-generated", "category": "rollback", "title_en": "No rollback artifact is generated", "title_tr": "Rollback artifact'ı üretilmiyor", "method": "capability_boundary", "expected_decision": "INDETERMINATE", "actual_decision": "INDETERMINATE", "passed": true, "failures": [], "old_url_count": null, "new_url_count": null, "deployable_count": null, "review_count": null, "risk_codes": [ "rollback_not_evaluated" ], "receipt_core_valid": null, "artifact_hash_parity": null, "generated_artifact_count": 10, "boundary": "The engine runbook asks the operator to retain the prior configuration, but the packet does not capture or hash that external rollback artifact." } ] }